Yeah, I know you trust us, and I know we would only be cheating ourselves, and I said so ten days ago
==================================================================
My suggestion would be to advise us how to use something which is going to be as accurate as possible so we all know we've done our best to get it right, and carry on with the 'honesty box' approach, because
a) Even with a widget, anyone can cheat - copy and paste a few pages in to get the numbers up - hell, it could all be complete rubbish or stolen from scriptorama anyway, and
b) If you cheat, *you* will know you cheated and
c) We're not going to cheat because everyone here is doing it for FUN!
==================================================================
The point of mentioning the blank business cards was to indicate that the validation widget doesn't check the number of words, it doesn't check the size of the pages, and it doesn't even check there is any content at all. Now I assumed that this was a bug that needed reporting because I assumed that a validation widget would validate things enough to reject 78 tiny blank pages as being 'not a proper script', at least. I thought that it would look at the contents of the file, reformat it to its own specification and report the number of pages when it is formatted that way thus giving Screnziers a benchmark figure for their script.
Please don't think I'm picking on you, I know you do all this for coffee and free trips in the Screnzy helicopter, but there are a number of points that your widget doesn't address:
a) What is the point of a widget which is more trouble than just typing in the number of pages when it does absolutely no checking at all and the person uploading the PDF has just made the PDF and knows perfectly well how many pages are in it - (the same as in the script they made the PDF from)?
b) This doesn't help people who have 20,000 words and 30 pages who would like to ensure that they are formatting their script correctly.
c) This does not allow Screnzy to level the playing field, i.e. there is no way to find out if my 100 pages is equvalent to someone else's 100 pages.
d) What was the point of all the days and days of talk about 'they're working on it' when all you seem to have done is:
==================================================================
PdfReader reader = PdfReader.fileReader(filename);
PdfDocument doc = new PdfDocument(reader);
int pageCount = doc.getPageCount());
==================================================================
and then you stick the page count in the database?
Some people want it official. Personally I'm not worried, but as a programmer, I was interested to see how sophisticated the validation would be, and thought the least I could do was a bit of testing.
Other people want the 'official stamp' - Lousy Writer 13 said: I don't care what standard is chosen, just that we choose one...[snip]...The "Script Frenzy standard" is what needs to be published and followed by the widget and none of the other standards really matter to me,
But there is no Script Frenzy standard, is there? And I get the impression that a lot of people were hoping there would be.
Ian
|